J. van Brakel (1994) Cognitive Scientism of Science
. Psycoloquy: 5(07) Scientific Cognition (3)
Versions: ASCII formatted
Psycoloquy 5(07): Cognitive Scientism of Science
COGNITIVE SCIENTISM OF SCIENCE
Commentary on Giere on Science-Cognition
J. van Brakel
Department of Philosophy
University of Utrecht
P.O. Box 80.126
3508 TC Utrecht (The Netherlands)
brakel@phil.ruu.nl
Abstract
In this review of Cognitive Models of Science (CSS, Giere
1992), I express skepticism about its ability to (dis)solve all
foundational issues concerning science and suggest that CSS would
do better to redirect its attention to the foundational problems
that beset cognitive science itself. Not only CSS but the social
and philosophical approaches to science too are, in their extreme
forms, caricatures, based on the same scientistic model. What is
needed instead is a recognition of the priority of the Manifest
Image over the Scientific Image.
Keywords
Cognitive science, philosophy of science, cognitive
models, artificial intelligence, computer science, cognitve
neuroscience.
References