Summary of PSYCOLOQUY topic Coma Biochemistry

Topic:
Title & AuthorAbstract
10(026) THE BIOCHEMICAL BASIS OF COMA
Target Article on Coma-Biochemistry
John Smythies
Division of Neurochemistry
Brain and Perception Laboratory
Center for Brain and Cognition
University of California, San Diego
La Jolla CA 92093-0109
and
Department of Neuropsychiatry
Institute of Neurology
Queen Square, London

smythies@psy.ucsd.edu
Abstract: Current research on the neural basis of consciousness is based mainly on neuroimaging, physiology and psychophysics. This target article reviews what is known about biochemical factors that may contribute to the development of consciousness, based on loss of consciousness (i.e., coma). There are two theories of the biochemical mode of action of general anaesthetics. One is that anaesthesia is a direct (i.e., not receptor-mediated) effect of the anaesthetic on cellular neurophysiological function; the other is that some alteration of receptor function occurs. General anaesthetics are mainly GABA agonists but some (such as ketamine) are glutamate antagonists. They also affect other systems, particularly cholinergic ones. There are various comas of metabolic origin. For example, a combination of small doses of the iron chelators desferrioxamine and prochlorperazine induce a profound and long lasting coma in humans. The mechanisms that might mediate this include redox mechanisms at the glutamate synapse, post-synaptic endocytosis of dopamine and iron, and intracellular iron-dopamine complexes, which are powerful dismuters of the superoxide anion. New findings in cell biology relating to endocytosis and recycling of receptors are discussed in a wider context. These biochemical events may induce coma by two mechanisms: (i) Consciousness may depend on widespread cortical (or cortico-thalamic) activation. (ii) Whereas these biochemical changes are widespread, only the changes in a subset of 'consciousness' neurons may count. An experimental program to distinguish between these two alternatives is proposed.

Keywords: anaesthetics, coma, consciousness, desferrioxamine dopamine, GABA, general glutamate iron, redox mechanisms, synapses

11(031) NEUROBIOCHEMISTRY OF COMA: MONOAMINERGIC SYSTEM INTERACTIONS
Commentary on Smythies on Coma-Biochemistry
Jiankang Liu
Division of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology
University of California, Berkeley CA 94720-3202
and
Children's Hospital
Oakland Research Institute
Oakland, CA 94609-1673

jiank@uclink4.berkeley.edu
Abstract: All neurotransmitters may be involved in coma, with interactions between receptor-mediated and non-receptor-mediated functions.

Keywords: anaesthetics, coma, consciousness, desferrioxamine dopamine, GABA, general glutamate iron, redox mechanisms, synapses

11(032) CRUCIAL ROLE OF IRON IN ANESTHESIA
Commentary on Smythies on Coma-Biochemistry
Richard M. Kostrzewa
Department of Pharmacology
Quillen College of Medicine
East Tennessee State University
PO Box 70, 577
Johnson City, TN 37614.
http://www2.etsu.edu/HTBIN/PH/nameserver/105

Kostrzew@ETSU.edu
Abstract: Despite the consensus that glutamatergic and GABAergic imbalance is likely to be involved in anesthesia or coma, there is little known about molecular mechanisms of action of gaseous anesthetics. The target article by Smythies (1999) is engagingly analytical and insightful, proposing novel and testable hypotheses for the molecular mechanisms of action of anesthetics as well as for processes that may be involved in coma. The most creative and convincing of his hypotheses concerns the crucial role of iron in maintaining neural respiration and energy production as well as its involvement in synaptic plasticity. Smythies' paper is certain to stimulate new ideas and experiments on the molecular mechanisms of anesthesia and coma.

Keywords: anaesthetics, coma, consciousness, desferrioxamine dopamine, GABA, general glutamate iron, redox mechanisms, synapses