Robert M. Hamm (1994) Underweighting of Base-rate Information Reflects Important
. Psycoloquy: 5(03) Base Rate (7)
Versions: ASCII formatted
Psycoloquy 5(03): Underweighting of Base-rate Information Reflects Important
UNDERWEIGHTING OF BASE-RATE INFORMATION REFLECTS IMPORTANT
DIFFICULTIES PEOPLE HAVE WITH PROBABILISTIC INFERENCE
Commentary on Koehler on Base-Rate
Robert M. Hamm
Clinical Decision Making Program
Department of Family Medicine
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center
Oklahoma City OK 73190 USA
rob-hamm@@uokhsc.edu
Abstract
I argue that people do a poor job integrating informative
base rates into their decision processes. This is shown by the
results of two sorts of study. First, in probabilistic inference
word problems, people's interpretations of conditional
probabilities are confused. Second, in studies where subjects
receive a series of pieces of information and update their
probabilities after each, their probability updating is inaccurate,
reflecting several error-producing processes, including
overweighting of most recent information, which is usually not the
base-rate information. We should not ask how much this matters,
without considering that experts who make consequential decisions
based on their hypotheses about the state of the world usually
follow rule-like scripts, rather than explicitly revise
probabilities.
Keywords
Base rate fallacy, Bayes' theorem, decision making,
ecological validity, ethics, fallacy, judgment, probability.
References
- Abernathy, C.M., and Hamm, R.M. (in press, 1994). Surgical Intuition. Philadelphia, PA: Hanley and Belfus.
- Adelman, L., Tolcott, M.A., and Bresnick, T.A. (1993). Examining the Effect of Information Order on Expert Judgment. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 56, 348-369.
- Anderson, J.R., and Milson, R. (1989). Human Memory: an Adaptive Perspective. Psychological Review, 96, 783-719.
- Ayton, P. (1993). Base Rate Neglect: an Inside View of Judgment? Commentary on Koehler on Base-rate. PSYCOLOQUY 4(63) base-rate.5.ayton.
- Bar-Hillel, M. (1980). The Base-rate Fallacy in Probability Judgments. Acta Psychologica, 44, 211-233.
- Bernstein, L.H., Rudolph, R.A., Pinto, M.M., Viner, N., and Zuckerman, H. (1990). Medically Significant Concentrations of Prostate-specific Antigen in Serum Assessed. Clinical Chemistry, 36, 515-518.
- Carter, B.L., Butler, C.D., Rogers, J.C., and Holloway, R.L. (1993). Evaluation of Physician Decision Making With the Use of Prior Probabilities and a Decision-analysis Model. Archives of Family Medicine, 2, 529-534.
- Chapman, G.B., Bergus, G.R., Gjerde, C., and Elstein, A.S. (1993). Sources of Error in Reasoning about a Clinical Case: Clinicians as Intuitive Statisticians (Meeting Abstract). Medical Decision Making, 13, 382.
- Christensen-Szalanski, J.J.J. (1986). Improving the Practical Utility of Judgment Research. In B. Brehmer, H. Jungermann, P. Lourens, and G. Sevon (Eds.), New Directions in Research on Decision Making (pp. 383-410). North Holland: Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.
- Christensen-Szalanski, J.J.J., and Beach, L.R. (1982). Experience and the Base-rate Fallacy. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 29, 270-278.
- Christensen-Szalanski, J.J.J., and Bushyhead, J.B. (1981). Physicians' Use of Probabilistic Information in a Real Clinical Setting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 7, 928-935.
- Dawes, R.M. (1986). Representative Thinking in Clinical Judgment. Clinical Psychology Review, 6, 425-441.
- Dawes, R.M., Mirels, H.L., Gold, E., and Donahue, E. (1993). Equating Inverse Probabilities in Implicit Personality Judgments. Psychological Science, 4, 396-400.
- Eddy, D.M. (1982). Probabilistic Reasoning in Clinical Medicine: Problems and Opportunities. In D. Kahneman, P. Slovic, and A. Tversky (Eds.), Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases (pp. 249-267). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Edwards, W. (1968). Conservatism in Human Information Processing. In B. Kleinmuntz (Ed.), Formal Representation of Human Judgment (pp. 17-52). New York: Wiley.
- Gregson, R.A.M. (1993). Which Bayesian Theorem Could Be Compared With Real Behavior? Commentary on Koehler on Base-rate. PSYCOLOQUY 4(50) base-rate.2.gregson.
- Hamm, R.M. (1987). Diagnostic Inference: People's Use of Information in Incomplete Bayesian Word Problems. (Publication No. 87-11). Boulder, CO: Institute of Cognitive Science, University of Colorado.
- Hamm, R.M. (1989). People Misinterpret Conditional Probabilities: Final Report of Project Using Protocol Analysis and Process Tracing Techniques to Investigate Probabilistic Inference (Publication No. 89-4). Boulder, CO: Institute of Cognitive Science, University of Colorado.
- Hamm, R.M. (1993). Explanations for Common Responses to the Blue/Green Cab Probabilistic Inference Word Problem. Psychological Reports, 72, 219-242.
- Hamm, R.M., and Miller, M.A. (1988). Interpretation of Conditional Probabilities in Probabilistic Inference Word Problems. (Publication No. 88-15). Boulder, CO: Institute of Cognitive Science, University of Colorado.
- Hogarth, R.M., and Einhorn, H.J. (1992). Order Effects in Belief Updating: The Belief-adjustment Model. Cognitive Psychology, 24, 1-55.
- Koehler, J.J. (1993). The Base Rate Fallacy Myth. PSYCOLOQUY 4(49) base-rate.1.koehler.
- Kuipers, B., Moskowitz, A.J., and Kassirer, J.P. (1988). Critical Decisions Under Uncertainty: Representation and Structure. Cognitive Science, 12, 177-210.
- Meyer, K.B., and Pauker, S.G. (1987). Screening for HIV: Can We Afford the False Positive Rate? New England Journal of Medicine, 317, 238-241.
- Ofir, C. (1988). Pseudodiagnosticity in Judgment Under Uncertainty. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 42, 343-363.
- Penney, C.G. (1992). Why Can't My Students Understand Conditional Probability? Paper presented at annual meetings of Psychonomics Society, St. Louis.
- Pollatsek, A., Well, A.D., Konold, C., Hardiman, P., and Cobb, G. (1987). Understanding Conditional Probabilities. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 40, 255-269.
- Pozen, M.W., D'Agostino, R.B., Selker, H.P., Sytkowski, P.A., and Hood, W.B., Jr. (1984). A Predictive Instrument to Improve Coronary-care-unit Admission Practices in Acute Ischemic Heart Disease: A Prospective Multicenter Clinical Trial. New England Journal of Medicine, 310, 1273-1278.
- Riesbeck, C.K., and Schank, R.C. (1989). Inside Case-based Reasoning. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers.
- Robinson, L.B., and Hastie, R. (1985). Revision of Beliefs When a Hypothesis Is Eliminated From Consideration. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 11, 443-456.
- Schmidt, H.G., Norman, G.R., and Boshuizen, H.P.A. (1990). A Cognitive Perspective on Medical Expertise: Theory and Implications. Academic Medicine, 65, 611-621.
- Spellman, B.A. (1993). Implicit Learning of Base Rates: Commentary on Koehler on Base-rate. PSYCOLOQUY 4(61) base-rate.4.spellman.
- Tolcott, M.A., Marvin, F.F., and Lehner, P.E. (1989). Expert Decision Making in Evolving Situations. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 19, 606-615.
- Tubbs, R.M., Gaeth, G.J., Levin, I.P., and Van Osdol, L.A. (1993). Order Effects in Belief Updating with Consistent and Inconsistent Evidence. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 6, 257-269.